
A History of Conspiracy Theories
It is tempting to see conspiracy theories as being a purely modern phenomenon. They exist purely because our gargantuan modern networks of Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok allow them to. They accelerate radical and unfounded views like a particle accelerator until they achieve a kind of nuclear fission of anger, hate and suspicion. They provide ‘’recommendations’’ so that those who search for anything conspiratorial in nature will find plenty of it and they are the main cause of misinformation in the 21st century.
The technology may be new, but nothing else is. A belief in conspiracy has been endemic to humanity for as long as history has been recorded. You see we are not and never have been rational animals. The burden of proof which has crushed so many in their search for knowledge and wisdom has just as easily been cast off and thrown to the ground by those who wish to redefine the parameters of whatever discourse they seek to participate in. In plain English- who needs evidence if you want to believe that something is true?
Unfortunately, and due to the tribal nature of humans, those who are often blamed or held in suspicion of organising secret conspiracies often are in ‘othered’ groups. This is almost always a minority of some description and the first of these examples is the Jews, perhaps the ultimate target for conspiracy theories.
Jews throughout History have always held on to their unique culture even when around other groups. A lack of interest in converting non-Jews and a pride in their heritage meant that Jewish communities throughout history often did not assimilate into the dominant society they existed within. Even though in the vast majority of cases these Jews were peaceful and law-abiding members of this wider society they were often blamed for conspiracies dreamt up by their neighbours. This was usually because of economic jealousy in Western Europe as Jews often occupied high skilled and paid jobs and often occupied financial positions in banking (due to the Christian position on usury- they were forbidden to charge interest- which was did not go against Jewish religious laws) whilst the majority of local people of different faiths would have held broadly speaking lower skilled and paid jobs. The great irony of this is that Jewish run banks often became crucial parts of the financial system of Christian Europe, as the modern need for credit and loans in business became largely incompatible with the position on usury.
Jews thus looked different, practiced a different religion, often spoke a different language to each other (Hebrew or Yiddish mostly) and in some cases earnt a lot of money. This meant that when times were tough they became targets for irrational rage and jealously. The Crusades of the eleventh century were accompanied by widespread and brutal massacres of Jews around Europe and then Jews were expelled from the Crimea in 1016, Silesia in 1159, France in 1182, England and Wales in 1290, Germany in 1348, Hungary in 1349, Austria in 1421, Lithuania in 1445, Spain in 1492, Sicily in 1492, Portugal in 1497, Tunis in 1535 and the Papal States in 1569. Jews were slowly allowed back legally into these countries within the following centuries (in England and Wales when Cromwell was in charge almost four centuries after their expulsion) but in the mean time they flocked to the few countries which allowed them to live in peace such as the Netherlands and Poland. Antisemitism was rife in Europe even after Jews were allowed back into most countries and reached a climax, as we know, in the twentieth century.
Jews were often murdered on the totally invented charges of sacrificing Christian children in some kind of blood ritual to try and arouse anger, as well as being described as ‘parasites’, ‘leeches’ and ‘aliens’ for their economic importance. Nazi propaganda made use of all of these themes and blamed Jews for Germany’s economic ruin in the 1920’s and for losing the First World War in 1918.
Jews are still a target for conspiracy theorists in current climate and as you can see, this has sadly been going on for a thousand years.
Other conspiracy theories in History have shown us that the modern practice is nothing new. One of the most famous was a campaign orchestrated by U.S Senator Joseph McCarthy at the height of the Cold War in the USA. From the early to the mid 1950’s, when fear was rife in the USA about a potential hydrogen bomb attack from the Soviet Union, McCarthy claimed in February 1950 that he had a list of ‘members of the Communist Party and members of a spy ring’ who were employed in the US State Department. He then stoked fears about Communist spies in government using accusations which included; communism, communist sympathies, disloyalty and sex crimes (such as homosexuality, which was illegal in the USA at the time and was seen to make somebody vulnerable to blackmail). This gave him enormous personal influence and led to thousands of federal employees being sacked on baseless charges because US lawmakers ended up approving investigations from McCarthy’s accusations. McCarthy’s personal power grew and grew but he soon picked a target he could not win against as he soon was demanding members of the Army be sacked for communist sympathies, including a number of war heroes from the Second World War. This led public opinion to turn sharply against him.
These two examples of conspiracy theories, the persecution of the Jews and of McCarthy and his ‘Red Scare’ in the USA in the 1950’s, show just how embedded the practice of conspiracies are in History. They may change and ebb and flow with their hysteria but they seem to arise under pressure such as economic, social or military hardship or fears. Perhaps History can teach us lessons about who and what to believe or, even better, to question the things we hear about?