
Dying for an Idea- A Historical Discussion
On the outbreak of the English Civil War in the mid-17th century, prominent royalist and King Charles I standard bearer Sir Edmund Verney wrote to his son Ralph (who decided to support the Parliamentarians) to justify his decision to side with the King;
‘’I have eaten his bread and served him near thirty years, and will not do so base a thing as to forsake him; and choose rather to lose my life (which I am sure to do) to preserve and defend those things which are against my conscience to preserve and defend’’ Verney Memoirs, London, 1892 Vol. I, p. 277
Sir Edmund was killed at the Battle of Edgehill in 1642 and he certainly died for his beliefs. He was by no means a cast iron royalist- he disapproved of many aspects of King Charles I’s tyranny- but he was willing to lay down his life, eventually doing so, for the idea of loyalty to his King. This idea of loyalty to a king or leader and the willingness to die for this idea is one which is extremely across cultures and throughout History but has died out in many ways across large parts of the world. Why did people so willingly give their lives for ideas when it goes against the most basic survival instinct in humans? This article will look at a few reasons why.
One of the main reasons is that humans are not and have never been rational logical creatures. Basic survival instincts presupposes an ability to think clearly and judge a situation on its merits but in reality this rarely happens. Ideas, when they are powerful enough, cut across logical thinking and instead activate our emotional impulses, which are far more powerful and on top of this they give meaning to our lives (even if this meaning is unpleasant and destructive). Meaning is what some humans crave more than security or material comfort or even life itself. In the classic Russian novel Crime and Punishment, Fyodor Dostoyevsky writes through the character of Razumikhin his critique of Socialism and how it ignores human nature;
‘’That’s why they instinctively dislike history, ‘nothing but ugliness and stupidity in it,’ and they explain it all as stupidity! That’s why they so dislike the living process of life; they don’t want a living soul! The living soul demands life, the soul wont obey the rules of mechanics, the soul is an object of suspicion, the soul is retrograde!’’
The living soul, according to Dostoyevsky, is irrational, unpredictable and demands life. It demands ideas and meaning and it is retrograde, meaning it does not always do what is strictly correct to preserve itself.
In many historical societies the existential concept of loyalty to a lord was especially strong in Northern European societies. The Anglo-Saxon poem ‘The Wanderer’ spoke of the waking death and extreme sense of grief and loss of a warrior who was left alive after his lord had been killed in battle. The epic poem The Battle of Maldon speaks of the Anglo-Saxon hero Brythnoth who laid down his life battling Viking invaders for his king. Even the enlightened Aelfred the Great had an almost fanatical idea of the loyalty his subjects should show their lord.
I have been talking about secular beliefs so far but of course religion has provided one of the most powerful sets of ideas for people to die for and they often continue doing so today in some parts of the world with sectarian violence. Christian crusades and Islamic jihad offer the most extreme large scale examples of being willing to die for one’s religion, with many millions perishing in the past thousand years for each of these religions.
As the centuries passed and the two great world religions started an uneasy truce between each other, they started fighting amongst themselves, Catholic versus Protestant and Sunni versus Shia. Religion then largely took a backseat altogether as the two great modern religions took hold of the minds of billions- Capitalism versus Communism. Psychologically speaking, whether religious or secular all of these ideas gave their followers the same sense of meaning which all humankind craves. They activated the ‘living soul’ to use the phrase Dostoyveksy used and thus people lost all logical perspective and in many cases were willing to die for said ideas. All of these ideas give meaning to lives which throughout history, often lacked any control over themselves. To give an example- for a landless peasant in a feudal society or a destitute worker in a factory, powerful ideas gave them a sense of belonging and meaning in world which to paraphrase Thomas Hobbes was often ‘Nasty, Brutish and Short’.
Of course there is another motivation for giving ones life for an idea and that is morals. The examples of this throughout history are reserved for a fairly select few for the most part, as dying for a moral cause implies those who die do not have the backing of a large group (as almost all of the ideas mentioned possessed). The strength of a person’s convictions are often so powerful that they will become more important that life itself. It is impossible to show all of the examples which deserve to be mentioned but the one which always strikes me the most is that of the German soldier Anton Schmidt. In the Second World War Shmidt helped over 300 Jews, saving them from almost certain death and was eventually caught by his superiors and executed. He is one of only three German soldiers who were executed for helping the Jews during the war. In his last letters to his wife, Schmidt, a devout Christian guided by his morals, wrote;
“My dear Steffi,
As I think of you in joy and in sorrow, I inform you, my dearest, that my verdict has been announced today and that I must part from this world, for I have been sentenced to death. Please put your trust in God who decides all our destinies.
I could not change anything, otherwise I would have spared you and Greta all this. Please forgive me. I did not wish to cause you this pain, but unfortunately there is no way back. I am prepared to die since this is the will of God and His will must be done. You must reconcile yourself to this. And once again, I ask you two, the dearest to me in all the world, please forget the pain I’m causing you, and keep your peace. After all, all I did was to save human lives, even if they were Jews, and in doing so, I sealed my own fate. As I have always done, I acted only for the sake of others, and so I sacrificed everything for my fellow men.
My dear ones, I beg you again and again, please forget me. Everything is ordained, it is what fate willed. I conclude these lines and send my blessing and and kisses to both of you and to all those close to me in this world and the next, where God will speedily take me into his arms.
Loving you for eternity,
Toni” (letter from Yad Vashem’s website)
Schmidt is honoured in Yad Vashem as a ‘Righteous among Nations’.
Many throughout History have laid down their lives for an idea and as we have seen in this article it seems to boil down to giving meaning to one’s life and giving the soul something to live for. Whether it be loyalty to a lord, adherence to a religion, belief in a capitalist/communist society or a belief in compassion or morality, these ideas have shaped History and have led hundreds of millions to lay down their lives.