
'Eat, Drink and Be Merry, For Tomorrow we Die'. Why we Cannot Understand History if we Shy Away from Death
Prior to Covid 19, Never had the wealthy western world been so sheltered from death. Never had we as a society been so far removed from the bare facts of our own mortality. The one unifying fact that unites all humanity, the single certainty in everyone’s life from the highest nobility to the lowliest peasant- we will all die. This may seem a grim way to start an article but I say this because Historical attitudes throughout all History have been shaped by a fundamental awareness of this fact. In the vast majority of human history life was far far shorter than it is now in the western world. In the UK the average life expectancy has risen from just over 35 years old in 1770 to just over 81 in 2020. In 250 years we have on average over doubled the amount of time we spend alive. How can we ignore this fact when we start to analyse historical attitudes and mindsets?
Human life expectancy hovered around the 30-40 mark for most of human history. This of course meant that these existential questions which all humans share in their heart of hearts were of critical importance. If death could take you at any moment then it is far more important to be at peace with that fact as much as is possible. This led to many different ways of grappling the questions of our own mortality. This is why religions of all types were so central to the way the vast majority of humans saw their world for thousands of years- it could help to answer the questions of why we are here, where we can go and most crucially of all, what meaning we can gain from life. It is fashionable for us to in the 21st century to look upon the devout masses of the Middle Ages as being crude and backwards but we fundamentally misunderstand their world if we think that our modern secular views are at all applicable to theirs.
To give an example; imagine if you yourself were transported to the Middle Ages. You know about gravity, that the earth revolves around the sun, that illnesses are spread through bacteria and viruses and that The New World (The Americas) lie just on the other side of the Atlantic Ocean. How would you prove any of these things to the people around you? How would you stop a Smallpox epidemic ravaging local villages just through knowing vaguely how vaccination works but with no equipment or lab? How would you sail to the Americas if you have no skills in navigation and no suitable ships? How would you prove that the earth revolves around the sun with no astronomical skills? If you could prove none of these things then you would feel just as helpless and beholden to fate as they did. To paraphrase Isaac Newton, we know these things because we stand on the shoulders of giants, not because we ourselves are any more capable than people throughout history. The same applies to death. Why would a Medieval person live like us if they had no statistical guarantee of living past 35 years old? If your life was shortened to this extent then you would probably spend much of your time thinking of spiritual matters rather than material ones too.
These facts of life meant that thinkers and philosophers often pondered what ways there were grapple with these existential realities. Epicureanism was one of the first of these in the Western World. It was founded in around 307BC by Epicurus. It advocated that pleasure was the chief good in life but emphasis was placed on pleasure of the mind rather than of the body, shying away from overindulgence as excess led to suffering. It sought to eliminate fear of the Gods and fear of death and to focus on friendships. Epicureanism sought not to deny the existence of Gods but instead to deny that they have any effect on the world around us. The Epicurean secret for a happy life is brilliantly summed up by a piece of writing by the Roman era Epicurean Philodemus of Gadara in his writings in the Herculaneum Papyri found preserved in the Herculaneum Villa after the eruption of Mt Vesuvius in 79AD. He himself inherited it from an anonymous Epicurean, and he wrote is as the Tetrapharmakos (‘The Four Part Cure’):
Don’t fear God
Do not worry about death;
What is good is easy to get, and
What is terrible is easy to endure
If we replace God with ‘Work’, ‘Society’ or ‘Others’, we can easily apply this to a 21st century life. ‘What is good’ in this sense is peace of mind, friendships, freedom from fear and artistic pleasure. ‘Easy to endure’ means that all suffering even if extreme will always end.
This same attitude of embracing life as it is lived was shared by many other religions and beliefs too. The oft repeated phrase ‘Eat, Drink and Be Merry, For Tomorrow we die’ is actually an amalgamation of two different biblical verses. One is Isaiah 22:13 which reads;
But see, there is joy and revelry,
slaughtering of cattle and killing of sheep,
eating of meat and drinking of wine!
“Let us eat and drink,” you say,
“for tomorrow we die!”
The other is from Ecclesiastes 8:15, which reads;
So I commend the enjoyment of life, because there is nothing better for a person under the sun than to eat and drink and be glad. Then joy will accompany them in their toil all the days of the life God has given them under the sun.
Both of these verses show an acute awareness that life is short, life is precious and that life is worth living. This carried through the centuries and millennia and is perhaps best summed up by the poet John Dryden who wrote ‘Happy the Man’ as a funeral oration for one of his dear friends published in 1685;
Happy the man, and happy he alone,
He who can call today his own:
He who, secure within, can say,
Tomorrow do thy worst, for I have lived today.
Be fair or foul or rain or shine
The joys I have possessed, in spite of fate, are mine.
Not Heaven itself upon the past has power,
But what has been, has been, and I have had my hour.
We must always remember that in the Western World, our perceptions of life and death have been massively altered in the last two and half centuries by the advancements of medicine and science and that for the vast majority of human history, death was a part of life and this put extra emphasis on living the life we are given as well as possible. Perhaps the Covid 19 pandemic will make the Western World talk about and thinking about death more, rather than hiding it away from all aspects of society? Only time will tell.