top of page
5402440804_5f904cf07b_b.jpg

How Should We Portray Evil?

I watched a film on the weekend. It is a film I have seen many times before but I watched it again because for me it cuts to the core of History and humanity. It is ‘Downfall’, the 2004 film about Hitler and his entourage in the final days of the Battle of Berlin in April 1945. It shows Hitler as a sick (he had Parkinsons it is widely assumed), frail, pathetic and delusional old man, ranting and raving at his generals whilst simultaneously being kind, courteous and generous to his secretary, maid, wife and friends. It shows Hitler, the ultimate symbol of human depravity and evil, as a person. As much as it sickens me, I almost felt sorry for this pathetic person, left to die and be swallowed up by the awful events he unleashed upon the world- much like someone would feel sorry for a rabid dog. Interspersed amongst these moments of humanity Hitler (portrayed fantastically by Swiss actor Bruno Ganz) also talks with wistful pride of his extermination of the Jews, his belief that all compassion is weakness and his belief that the German people deserved their fate.

​

I did not write this as a film review- but the film itself is a great example of why we cannot separate evil from humanity. It had been a convenient myth for much of the post war generation (especially in Germany) to push all of the evils of the Nazi regime onto the Nazi high command and the almost cartoonish evil of Hitler, Goebbels, Himmler and Goring etc. The others were supposedly duped into Nazism, only following orders upon pain of death and being helpless to stem the tide of the events in question. This was particularly emphasised in the memoirs of Albert Speer (Hitler’s chief armaments minister and architect), called Erinnerungen (Memories), where he absolved himself from knowledge of Nazi atrocities pleading ignorance and his sense of duty. Luckily for Speer, evidence of his knowledge of the Final Solution and other crimes against humanity were never found at the time of the Nuremberg Trials. The historian Magnus Brechtken, who wrote ‘Albert Speer: Eine Deutsche Karriere’ claimed that if Speer’s involvement in the Holocaust were known during the Nuremberg Trials he would have been sentenced to death.

​

Speer’s myth of the ‘good Nazi’ gave millions of ex Nazi’s in Germany a way out of the moral quagmire they found themselves in at the end of the war. This is why the book was wildly successful when it was released in the 1960’s (once Speer’s 20 year prison sentence for utilising slave labour was finished). This post war scramble for justification really illustrates the historical problem of ‘evil’.

​

It has become extremely convenient to label certain figures in History as evil. It is far easier for us to imagine the figures such as Hitler, Stalin, Mao and others to be somehow supernaturally evil. They are the devil incarnate and they are not like us normal people. They themselves personally created evil regimes and these evil regimes died with them too. This makes it far easier for the rest of us to shoulder the guilt- chiefly as we don’t have to. We can bury the demons of the past with the demons who shaped it. This is a coping mechanism for all of us to try and process the fact that human beings- us included- are capable of the highest evil.

​

The famous Milgram Experiment conducted in 1961-3 at Yale University shined a light on some very uncomfortable home truths with regard to the human propensity to follow orders which are cruel and brutal. In this experiment there was a subject (subject 1) in a room strapped to a machine which would administer subject 1 an electric shock whenever another subject (subject 2) in a separate room moved a dial. There was a ‘scientist’ in the separate room with subject 2 who gave instructions about when the shock the other participant and about what severity the shocks could be. Unbeknownst to subject 2, the shocks administered to subject 1 were fake and did no harm but as the shocks were administered through the instructions of the scientist, subject 1 would cry out in pain which grew more and more severe as each shock was given. The voltage of the fake shocks increased to the point where it would have killed someone had the shocks been real. The cries of pain from subject 1 got more and more severe until they eventually stopped when the voltage became high enough. The shocking results of this experiment were that 65% of the subject 2 participants administered the huge 450v shock to subject 1, despite the cries of obvious pain and agony from subject 1- all because they had been instructed to carry on with the shocks. The other 35% all went at least as far as the 300v shock. This experiment has been repeated around the globe many times and has produced similar results. It shows how humans are in the majority of cases willing to inflict serious harm and agony on somebody if they are ordered to do it. Milgram actually devised the experiment to explain the psychology of genocide after the trial of Adolf Eichmann in Israel in the early 1960’s, whose defence was that he was following orders.

​

To return to the portrayal of Hitler in Downfall. Some critics pointed out that it humanised Hitler and thus made him a figure we can in some senses relate to. These critics would probably rather that the caricature of Hitler which we can comfortably push to the edge of the human experience is shown- one we can sneer at, ostracise and cast out from the human race forever. However, when we show Hitler as a human being just like us- it shows us the sometimes horrific truth- that we are all capable of evil through the choices we make and it is no excuse to just be following orders when it comes to horrific acts even if it seems the far easier way out. Portraying evil as a human characteristic rather than a supernatural characteristic is thus absolutely crucial when we discuss the evils of history.

How Should We Portray Evil?: Service

What did you think of this Article?

Thanks for submitting!

How Should We Portray Evil?: Add a Review

Keep up to date with all the latest Accessible History content by following us on Social Media using the links below! 

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

©2020 by Accessible History. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page