
How Single Decisions can Change the Course of History
Alexander Pope once wrote in ‘An Essay on Man’:
Know then thyself, presume not God to scan;
The proper study of mankind is man.
Plac'd on this isthmus of a middle state,
A being darkly wise, and rudely great:
With too much knowledge for the sceptic side,
With too much weakness for the stoic's pride,
He hangs between; in doubt to act, or rest;
In doubt to deem himself a god, or beast;
In doubt his mind or body to prefer;
Born but to die, and reas'ning but to err;
Alike in ignorance, his reason such,
Whether he thinks too little, or too much:
Chaos of thought and passion, all confus'd;
Still by himself abus'd, or disabus'd;
Created half to rise, and half to fall;
Great lord of all things, yet a prey to all;
Sole judge of truth, in endless error hurl'd:
The glory, jest, and riddle of the world!
This riddle of man as described by Alexander Pope in 1732 is as relevant today as it was back then- perhaps even more so! It is about the fundamental contradictions at the heart of human nature and humanity. We are born to only die, and we pursue intelligence only to make mistakes, we consider ourselves gods yet we worship others. We make uninformed, illogical and baffling choices at times but its our contradictory nature which makes it so!
This reminds me of something written by the Danish philosopher Soren Kierkegaard when he wrote
“Marry, and you will regret it; don’t marry, you will also regret it; marry or don’t marry, you will regret it either way. Laugh at the world’s foolishness, you will regret it; weep over it, you will regret that too; laugh at the world’s foolishness or weep over it, you will regret both. Believe a woman, you will regret it; believe her not, you will also regret it… Hang yourself, you will regret it; do not hang yourself, and you will regret that too; hang yourself or don’t hang yourself, you’ll regret it either way; whether you hang yourself or do not hang yourself, you will regret both. This, gentlemen, is the essence of all philosophy.”
The absolute contradiction of human nature! We cannot win, every action we take it caught in the same paradox- is that right? Should I have done something else? This has plagued men and women throughout History and there are numerous examples of how this has affected History. The idea that certain actions taken have altered History permanently stems from a similar type of reasoning- that we are in control of our destinies and all of our choices can have seismic effects. Sadly many of these choices are just as Pope and Kierkegaard fear and are due to the confusing riddle of humanity.
The old-fashioned word for this theory is the study of History is ‘Cleopatra’s Nose’. This is because it stemmed from the idea that if Cleopatra was not as beautiful, perhaps she would not have seduced Julius Caesar and Mark Antony, thus potentially changing History forever, thus the whole of modern western history stems from Cleopatra’s Nose!
This theory of History is now considered archaic but I do believe it has a place. Perhaps not in the sense of someone’s physical attributes but certainly with the choices they make. Choices made with what Kierkegaard and Pope had in mind; that every choice is the sole preserve of an individual, not forces, fate or providence. There are a number of examples of this.
The first example is that of Roman Emperor Constantine the Great. His conversion to Christianity at the Battle of Milvian Bridge on 28th October 312 AD meant that he was the first Roman Emperor to convert to Christianity and to protect Christians from persecution. Due to the fact that the majority of powerful Romans were still pagans and the time that change took time throughout the Empire, it must be argued that this change was Constantine’s choice alone. Even if Christianity had grown in spite of the Roman Empire, it would have taken a very different form than it has today if it had not received Imperial Patronage when it did. Constantine also converted when the Empire was in a position of strength (having just united the Empire under one rule after decades of strife) and so it can perhaps be seen as fortuitous that the Emperor converted to Christianity when the Empire was united and strong. As somebody’s conversion is an intensely personal thing, it was Constantine’s personal choice which arguably changed the world for millennia to come. What if Constantine had favoured the old gods? What if he had lost the Battle of Milvian Bridge and lost control of the Empire?
A second example is the decision of Henry VIII to establish the Church of England, dissolve and pinch the wealth from monasteries and forever split with Rome on religious issues. Now we know why Henry made this choice- he needed a divorce to marry Anne Boleyn as he was driven by the need for an heir, and money for foreign wars! but even Henry could not have known the enormous implication of his actions. From the mid-16th century onwards, with a few brief interludes of Catholic Monarchs (i.e his daughter Mary), England never was under the yoke of traditional Roman Catholicism. Never would the Catholic clergy own enormous amount of land and wealth in England and never would they prop up reactionary regimes like they would do in France and Spain in the 18th and 20th centuries respectively. Never would England be drawn into the horrific 30 years war of the 17th century which tore Europe apart between Catholic and Protestant and never would England be hamstrung intellectually or academically by the oppressive censorship of the church. Henry did not have to make this decision- his decision as we know was based on far more basic desires than the effects it caused. Considering there was no sign of any split from Rome before Henry VIII we can also assume that it was his own force of will and personality which caused this momentous decision, arguably forever changing English History. Had his first wife been able to produce a male heir- this would most likely never have happened!
The third example is that of Adolf Hitler deciding to declare war on the United States of America on 11th December 1941. This is by far the most baffling decision on this list and stands as one of the most bizarre decisions in the whole of History. The USA had declared war on Germany’s ally Japan four days earlier after the surprise attack on Pearl Harbour but Germany was under no obligation to join Japan in waging war against the USA. Had Hitler left the USA and Japan to fight then there would have been two wars happening worldwide, one in the Pacific and one in Europe. Under the terms of agreement Germany had with Japan, Germany would come to Japan’s aid if they were attacked by another nation but not if Japan was the aggressor (which was the case). The USA was at the time the richest, most powerful and most industrially advanced nation on earth and so any conventional wisdom (including by senior Nazis) wanted to keep them out of the war against them! Germany was also at this time being bogged down by the Russian winter as their invasion of the USSR was being stalled in Stalingrad and at the gates of Moscow. In spite of all of this Hitler still declared war on the USA and by all accounts it was his decision alone! This not only decisively turned the material, financial and political advantage towards the Allies but it also meant that Germany could no longer win the war outright, eventually being crushed completely with the capture of Berlin in April 1945. Hitler alone made this utterly irrational decision and it changed the outcome of World War Two, who could know what may have happened otherwise? It does not bear thinking about.
There you have it! Three decisions taken by three men, hundreds and sometimes thousands of years apart, which have quite literally changed history. It is certainly a riddle of man that means that personal choices of individuals, sometimes taken irrationally, can change the future in a thousand years! Perhaps this is what made Pope and Kierkegaard despair.