
Power Without Authority
We often talk of Power and Authority as being one and the same. They are two concepts which are used interchangeably when talking about politics and we have become rather numb to their true meanings but recent geopolitical events have really piqued me to look into these concepts further with regards to the US and UK governments currently.
Power, to paraphrase the 20th century German thinker Max Weber, is the ability to exercise one’s will over others. This can be violent or non-violent but the result is the same- your own will prevails. Power is a universal phenomenon and is exercised in every society around the world (as it can be through any means, it purely means somebody is in charge).
Authority is different. Authority is defined as legitimate power. Legitimacy means that people recognise and accept your power and that it is thus accepted by both ruler and those who are ruled, in effect giving it moral authority. The crucial thing about Authority is that it cannot come from the top-down, it must come from the bottom-up too. There are plenty of examples throughout History and the world today of rulers in power but with no authority- they tend to not last particularly long if they do not have some sort of popular support. As Boris Yeltsin once remarked ‘’You can make a throne of bayonets- but you cannot sit on it for long’’. Examples of powerful rulers with little Authority are military dictators, autocrats and with only a few exceptions they never last longer than a few years. The reason being that if you come to power through not respecting the legitimate authority of an established ruler, then you can hardly expect others to respect your own/confer you authority when you rule (often leading to coups, counter-revolutions and mass uprisings)! Where these regimes do last longer despite having no legitimate authority, it is almost always through state enforced terror, persecution and oppression- simply giving the populace no ability to show their displeasure and thus creating the illusion of authority.
Well-functioning democracies largely avoid this problem by letting the people choose their own ruler through voting systems. If a citizen’s choice wins they win they know their choice is in power (and thus has authority) and if they lose then they know that whoever is in charge was simply desired by more of the populace, hence still having Authority to rule even if its not their own personal choice. In these systems if a government loses Authority then they are simply voted out of power in the next election. What is fascinating is how ineffective Power is without Authority in a democracy, as the following points will illustrate.
One of the most fascinating illustrations of the difference between Power and Authority is currently playing out in front of our eyes. At the time of writing President Donald Trump has still not conceded to President Elect Joe Biden in the 2020 US Presidential Election almost three weeks after the election itself despite it being almost universally known that Biden has won the election by a fair margin both in terms of the popular vote as well as the electoral college. Trump is alleging massive widespread electoral fraud which has so far been completely unsubstantiated and in this time almost all of the major world leaders worldwide have already sought to call Biden and are starting to think about how his incoming administration will affect US policy towards the rest of the world. There are currently two Presidents, one de jure (Trump) and one de facto (Biden). The bizarre charade of the presidential transition period in the USA means we have a situation perfectly placed to look at the relationship between Power and Authority. Trump has all of the Power (as he is still the President) but increasingly he has little to no Authority. Biden has little to no Power (as he is not President until January 2021) but has all the Authority (being recognised almost universally around the world as the President Elect). This is where the current situations in the USA is so unprecedented- if supporters of President Trump decide to not view Biden as legitimate then there is a danger that his authority domestically will be eroded despite him winning the election. What would then stop whoever loses the 2024 election from doing exactly the same thing? This would lead to the office of President slowly becoming less and less effective, with less and less authority, until something would have to give as even elections themselves would become not recognised. The President would still be very powerful, but as we know, if that power is not bolstered by authority then it becomes very difficult to rule and for existing democratic systems to be maintained.
We are seeing this same drama played out to a lesser extent in the UK with the government and it’s coronavirus restrictions. Whilst the UK Government (especially one like Boris Johnson’s with a large parliamentary majority and no election for four years) is extremely powerful, It requires authority given to it by the people for these restrictions to actually work. This is why episodes such as Boris Johnson’s former advisor Dominic Cummings ignoring lockdown rules (and receiving no punishment or rebuke from Johnson despite widespread public outrage) caused so much anger as well as damage to the government. In a single instance, many people who had given the government and the lockdown rules authority and legitimacy then revoked this same authority, as the government was seen as hypocritical and wrong. Of course I am not saying that this derailed the government’s coronavirus response- but it did make it far harder for the government to retain that moral authority when asking others to make sacrifices and follow the rules. This is because the UK Government has no ability, and no desire to become a police state (where the illusion of authority can be achieved through terror, suppression and force) and so this moral authority is a very precious commodity to any government trying to implement wide ranging restrictions such as those which have been needed in 2020. If Johnson and his government are not careful, the erosion of it’s authority through blunders such as that committed by Cummings could make lockdowns and restrictions in name only- despite the huge power the government possesses.
So in conclusion, Power and Authority are very different things. Power exists everywhere in any governmental system whilst Authority is a far more precious accolade, only being able to be conveyed onto a government by the citizens itself. In both the USA and the UK at the moment there are reasons for governmental authority to be challenged and if authority is not restored then these governments will find it harder and harder to govern effectively and stay in power.